The Cup’s Half Full for Middle Eastern Feminists

Mon, Nov 9, 2009


Ms. Magazine / By Carole Joffe

Ms_CupHalfFullDespite shortcomings in its enforcement, CEDAW (Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women)—the United Nations’ international women’s rights treaty—has brought progress to women in the Middle East, according to women leaders from the region at a recent panel celebrating of its 30th anniversary.

The audience at the Washington, D.C., campus of Johns Hopkins University heard Wajeeha Al-Baharna, vice-president of the Bahrain Women’s Association, tell of a hard-fought victory in her country that allows women to pass on nationality to their children. And Asma Khader, of the Jordanian National Commission for Women, explained how CEDAW offered a framework that led to residency rights for women in her country. As several of the speakers pointed out, the very existence of CEDAW, even with imperfect enforcement, encourages women to mobilize politically—leading, for example, to an unusual local electoral victory by a Bedouin woman in Jordan and demands for domestic violence programs in several countries (even though CEDAW does not specifically address the latter).

The main message offered by all the women on the panel was that Middle Eastern women are ready to fight for their rights in ways not seen previously. As other Muslim feminists are doing, they raise objections to the “confiscation” of Islam by patriarchal clerics in their home countries, and argue that authentic Islam does not call for the subjugation of women demanded by contemporary interpretations of Sharia law.

CEDAW typifies both the promise and frustrations of U.N. treaties. To date, 187 member nations of the U.N. have ratified this treaty, with the U.S. being the only developed nation among a handful of holdouts. “The only thing that the U.S. and Iran probably agree on is their opposition to CEDAW,” joked Mahnaz Afkami, the former Minister for Women’s Affairs in Iran.

Theoretically, those countries that ratify CEDAW commit themselves to gender equality in their legal system, and “to establish tribunals and other public institutions to ensure the effective protection of women against discrimination.” Specific CEDAW Articles address such topics as voting rights, shared responsibilities for childcare, educational equity, property rights and equal access to health care.

Though all of the Middle Eastern countries represented by speakers at the event, except Iran, have ratified CEDAW, none have come close to implementing the various provisions of this Treaty. In part, this is because U.N. treaties have no enforcement mechanism, and also because CEDAW contains a provision by which countries can ratify it but express official reservations. Article16 is one of the most explosive within Muslim countries as it addresses the right to “freely choose a spouse” and stipulates equality in childrearing and divorce, and therefore numerous countries have expressed reservations about it.

In addition to CEDAW, the gathering in D.C. also celebrated the 10th anniversary of the founding of the Women’s Learning Partnership, an international NGO headed by Afkami, that works with 18 partnership organizations, primarily in Muslim-majority societies, to increase women’s leadership and empowerment. The event also marked the English-language release of the book, Iranian Women’s One Million Signatures Campaign for Equality, by Nousin Khorasani, an Iranian journalist now facing imprisonment by the Iranian government.

Even without CEDAW in Iran, women are mobilized to fight for their rights. The One Million Signatures campaign, which started several years ago, engaged hundreds of thousands of Iranian women and allied men to demand women’s equality, and laid the groundwork for the highly visible involvement of women in last summer’s protests against the disputed Iranian election. Equality may still be a long way off, but for Middle Eastern feminists the cup of equality is gradually filling.

Tags: , ,

About Mahnaz Afkhami

A lifetime advocate for the rights of women, Mahnaz Afkhami works with activists across the world, especially in Muslim majority societies, to help women become leaders. She is Founder and President of Women’s Learning Partnership for Rights, Development, and Peace (WLP), Executive Director of Foundation for Iranian Studies...more

Quotables – Human Rights

"We must pose the question: why is it that the denial of the most rudimentary rights to civil treatment for women is always based on some fundamental point of culture? Is this culture real, or is it a fetish that is used to maintain some economic, social, or simply psychological privilege?" - A Vision of Gender in Culture

"Women's status in society has become the standard by which humanity's progress toward civility and peace can be measured." - Architects for Peace

"The crass infringement of women's rights we see in the Muslim world has more to do with power, patriarchy, and misuse of religion as political weapon than with religion properly understood as individual faith." - Gender Apartheid, Cultural Relativism, and Women's Human Rights

"Rights and empowerment are interconnected: unless a substantial number of women in a community come to believe that they have rights and demand to exercise them, right remains an abstraction." - Faith and Freedom

Quotables – Muslim Women

"The most taxing contradiction [Muslim women] face casts the demands of living in the contemporary world against the requirements of tradition as determined and advanced by the modern Islamist world view. At the center of this conflict is the dilemna of Muslim women’s human rights – whether Muslim women have rights because they are human beings, or whether they have rights because they are Muslim" - Faith and Freedom: Introduction

"To the extent that Islam, defined and interpreted by traditionalist "Muslim" men, is allowed to determine the context and contour of the debate on women's rights, women will be on the losing side of the debate because the conclusion is already contained in the premise and reflected in the process. This is the heart of the moral tragedy of Muslim societies in our time." - Gender Apartheid, Cultural Relativism, and Women's Human Rights

“Islam is not the problem. Rather it is the misuse of Islam by interpreting it to fit the needs of the partriarchal order - the powers that be - and the privileges that one gender has held over the other.” - How are women working to eliminate violence against women in Muslim-majority societies?